Introducing a carbon tax that successfully reduces emissions whilst remaining revenue-neutral
Summary
In 2008, British Columbia, Canada introduced a revenue-neutral carbon tax on the purchase or use of fuel. It illustrates how to price carbon while managing the financial impact on consumers, particularly rural and low-income households through revenue recycling and tax credits. This case study focuses on the historical impacts of the carbon tax.
Challenge
Pricing of emissions is an effective market-based policy instrument for climate change mitigation. A carbon tax is a form of carbon pricing that puts a tax on emission-intensive goods and services, thereby incentivizing the production and consumption of low-emission alternatives. Despite the economic rationale and simplicity of policy design, implementation of carbon taxes has been slow due to perceived effects on economic growth, industrial competitiveness, and the regressivity of the tax burden. However, there is an incentive to limit the use of fossil fuels. Burning fossil fuels not only contributes to global warming but also worsens air pollution. In Canada this ‘costs thousands of lives and over $8 billion per year to Canada’s economy’ (World Bank).
An equity concern of carbon taxes is that they may be regressive, impacting low-income households, rural populations, and small businesses disproportionately.
Policy Goal + Expected Outcomes
In 2007, British Columbia set a target to reduce GHG 33% below 2007 levels by 2020 (British Columbia Government). Other actions the government is taking to tackle climate change include carbon capture schemes, introducing a fully electric bus fleet by 2040, engaging with Indigenous Nations on climate adaptation, and investing in hydrogen fuel (British Columbia Government).
The carbon tax was introduced in 2008 and covered 70% of GHG emissions. The tax was increased in phases, starting at 10 $CAD /ton and rising by 5 $CAD /ton each year (OECD, 2013). From 2013-2017 the tax was frozen, so that its progress and impact could be reviewed, but has continued to increase at 5 $CAD/ton per year since 2018 (NDC Partnerships). The tax is revenue neutral by design such that every dollar raised by the tax is returned to businesses and individuals via tax breaks or credits. Initially, all the tax revenue was levied to reduce other income and business taxes. In 2018, this policy was revised to enable some of the tax revenue to be spent on green investment. Throughout its iterations, however, the aspects of the policy designed to protect vulnerable groups were maintained.
These included, for example, support for:
- Low-income households
- Income tax cut implemented with the launch of the carbon tax, reducing the lowest personal income tax rates by 5% (World Bank)
- Climate action tax credit paid to eligible individuals with the size of credit based on family size and adjusted family net income (NDC Partnerships)
- Northern and rural homeowners
- Benefits of up to 200 $CAD (since 2011) (NDC Partnerships)
- Small businesses
- Tax cut in general corporate income tax from 12% to 11% (World Bank)
- An increase in the corporate income tax small business threshold to provide a business tax reduction to SMEs (NDC Partnerships)
Enabling conditions
Four key conditions allowed the implementation of the carbon tax:
- Strong political commitment compounded by a favourable political environment
- The implementation of the tax was pushed by the Premier at the time, Gordon Campbell.
- The government had strong supporters in the business sector, which gave them the power to introduce a tax without significant backlash (NDC Partnerships).
- British Columbia has a large availability of hydropower, a clean energy source, which facilitated the transition in response to the carbon tax as businesses could more cost-effectively shift away from fossil fuels.
- Strong public awareness of the impacts of climate change compounded by climate change-triggered events e.g. beetle infestation, intense storms
- In 2007, 20% of BC voters said climate change was the single most important issue (NDC Partnerships).
- Stakeholder engagement
- For example, after the tax was frozen in 2013 due to concerns about its economic competitiveness, the government established the Climate Leadership Team to evaluate its future (Partnership on Transparency in the Paris Agreement, 2019). The team included representatives from businesses, First Nations, local governments, academia, and environmental organisations.
- Clear plan of revenue recycling implementation to counter concerns the tax would be regressive
- The policy clearly laid out how the tax revenues would be used and the Minister of Finance had been required to submit a 3-year plan each year to communicate this.
Indicators of success
The carbon tax and its revenue-neutral approach delivered several positive impacts:
- Environmental impacts
- 5 years after the tax was introduced, fuel use had reduced by 16% (World Bank).
- It was estimated that emissions were reduced by 15% (Murray and Rivers, 2015).
- 7 companies from British Columbia are on the ‘2019 Global Cleantech 100’ list (NDC Partnership) and across British Columbia, 200 cleantech firms are generating 1.7 billion $CAD revenue (UNCCC).
- Economic impacts
- Economic studies find no negative impact of the tax on growth, or in some cases, a small positive impact e.g. Ahmadi and Yamazaki (2020) find an increase in output of 0.8% (NDC Partnership).
- Studies find an increase in overall employment, but this varies across sectors. For example, Yamazaki (2017) found a 0.75% annual increase. Azevedo et al (2023) found an increase in small business employment, likely due to the revenue recycling mechanism.
- Beck et al (2015) found that the carbon tax was progressive, due to the revenue recycling mechanism.
- Beck et al (2016) found that households in urban, rural, and small urban areas all saw a net benefit from the tax i.e. despite concerns, rural households weren’t made worse off.
- Support from citizens and business
- ‘Widespread global praise as a model for the world – from places like the OECD, the World Bank, and The Economist’ (World Bank)
- In 2016, 130 British Columbian businesses signed an open letter to the government calling for a lift of the carbon tax freeze.
- The tax was revenue-negative, it gave more back than it raised in the first five years.
The system is switching from its carbon pricing system for large industrial emitters to an output-based pricing system in April 2024 (“B.C. OBPS”). This was designed to ensure that emissions continue to reduce while providing companies with more flexible options such as carbon offsets (BC Gov). This switch highlights the challenges faced by jurisdictions that increase carbon prices, particularly as local industries compete with US and Asian counterparts that have low or no carbon pricing
Key Takeaways/Implications
- Highlights the utility of implementing a policy in phases to build support and leave time for business to adapt (i.e. increasing the taxable amount each year).
- Demonstrates the importance of building measures into the policy that protect vulnerable groups, not just to create a fairer policy but also to generate public support.
- Illustrates the importance of timing the introduction of a policy. The experience of negative climate effects in British Columbia leading up to 2008, and already established business support for the government created the right conditions to introduce the tax.