mobile image

California’s Advanced Clean Cars Program II

Summary

California’s Advanced Clean Cars program aims for all new cars and passenger trucks sold in California to be zero emission by 2035. Advanced Clean Cars I was adopted in 2012 and Advanced Clean Cars II was adopted in 2022. Advanced Clean Cars II includes the establishment of a zero-emission vehicles equity task force to ensure low-income and disadvantaged communities gain access to EVs. It illustrates how the government can utilise financial incentives and community investment to support low-income drivers through the transition.

 

Challenge

In 2022, California’s governor announced the state’s Net Zero Carbon Pollution Roadmap, which sets targets to reduce air pollution by 71% and greenhouse gas emissions by 85% by 2045. California is already experiencing the severe impacts of climate change including ‘catastrophic weather, extreme and prolonged drought, sea level rise and wildfires’ (California Air Resources Board). In 2023, the transport sector accounted for 39% of the state’s GHG emissions (California Air Resources Board). This high level of emission is partly due to insufficient investment in California’s public transportation system, which forces residents to over-rely on highways (TRIP). Internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles emit harmful compounds, including particulate matter and nitrogen oxides, which pose serious health risks. These adverse health effects are particularly severe in low-income communities and communities of colour (Energy Innovation). Low-income and disadvantaged communities face additional challenges as they typically have limited access to infrastructure and cannot afford EVs. In response to these challenges, the Advanced Clean Cars program was established to meet air quality and climate change emissions goals (California Air Resources Board).

 

The transition to zero-emission vehicles presents a significant equity challenge. In 2023, approximately 5 million Californians lived below the poverty line, defined as an annual income of less than £39,900 for a family of two adults and two children (PPIC). Consequently, regulations mandating the replacement of polluting vehicles with zero-emission vehicles pose an affordability challenge for many low-income households. There is a risk that such regulations could be regressive, disproportionately impacting those who can least afford to make the transition (Energy Innovation)

 

Programme Goal + Expected Outcomes 

The Advanced Clean Cars program is an initiative aimed at reducing vehicle emissions and promoting use of zero emission vehicles (ZEVs). The program began with the adoption of Advanced Clean Cars I in 2012 and was expanded with Advanced Clean Cars II in 2022. It integrates several regulations into one, including low-emission vehicles (LEV) criteria and greenhouse gas regulations. The primary goal of the program is to have 5 million ZEVs on the roads by 2030, by imposing LEV standards on manufacturers and mandating manufacturers to produce a certain proportion of ZEVs and hybrid vehicles each year (California Air Resources Board).

 

The program itself includes financial incentives to aid the switch to ZEVs or other modes of clean transportation. These incentives include rebates for new and used clean cars, funding for charging options, and funding for alternatives to owning a car e.g. car sharing and ride hailing. The incentives are backed by the Governor’s $2.4 billion dollar investment in vehicle incentives, charging infrastructure and public outreach (California Air Resources Board). Alongside this, measures such as minimum warranty and durability requirements, enhanced serviceability, and facilitated charging and battery labelling were established to ensure all consumers, especially those in lower-income and underserved communities where used vehicle sales are significant, could successfully replace their higher-polluting vehicles with new or used zero-emission vehicles(California Air Resources Board)


To guarantee the equitable implementation of the program, a ZEV equity taskforce was established to facilitate access to EVs for low-income and disadvantaged communities. This brings together leaders from various sectors including environmental justice advocates, automakers, state government representatives, and other key organizations. Their collective goal is to develop and implement strategies to expand access to ZEVs and zero-emission mobility in underserved communities. The taskforce operates through four specialized working groups:

  1. Clean mobility projects & incentives
    1. Focuses on selling new ZEVs or PHEVs at a 25% discount to qualifying community-based clean mobility programs.
    2. Program must be implemented by a local community-based organization
  2. Sales of EV
    1. Limitations on price at first sale (ZEV must have had a MSRP no more than $40,000 at first sale and for low-price EVs, the MSRP must be no greater than $20,275 for a car or $26,670 for a light truck)
    2. ZEV must be sold used at dealership participating in financial assistance programs
  3. Infrastructure
    1. Focuses on how to scale up infrastructure in disadvantaged communities to bolster ZEV deployment.
  4. Outreach & education
    1. In late 2024, the group will collaborate with Electrify America's Cycle 4 Proposed Investment Plan. Of the $5.7 million allocated by Electrify America for public education, awareness, access, and marketing activities in Cycle 4, $500,000 will specifically fund initiatives proposed by the ZEV Equity Task Force,
  5. Workforce development
    1. Focusing on connecting automakers with organizations and agencies that help people gain job skills to make car manufacturers’ training programs available to more people.

Enabling conditions

There are two key conditions to ensure that the implementation of the Advanced Clean Cars program was equitable:

  1. Consultation with local groups. The developers of the regulatory proposals engaged with national, state, and local advocacy organizations. They considered the recommendations from these groups on how to make zero-emission transportation more equitable (California Air Resources Board).
  2. Inclusion of Environmental Justice values. The program regulations include specific provisions (e.g., environmental justice credits) to encourage automakers actions that support the use of ZEVs in lower-income or disadvantaged communities and households – credits earned by automakers can contribute to their compliance with the sales requirement of the programme (California Air Resources Board)

Indicators of success

Overall, the Advanced Clean Cars program has seen success:

  • 17 states in the US have adopted versions of the programme (Advanced Clean Cars)
  • More than 35% of national new light-duty vehicle sales meet California automotive emissions standards (Advanced Clean Cars)

Specifically, the equity component of the program has seen success:

  • California has provided consumers with nearly $2 billion in incentives and rebates through programs like the Clean Vehicle Rebate Project and Clean Cars 4 All (CA Gov)
  • Currently, up to $24,500 in grants and rebates are available to replace vehicles for low-income consumers (CA Gov)
  • To qualify for the scheme, households must have an annual income below the income cap (based on household size): $45,180 for 1 person, $61,320 for 2 people, $93,600 for 4 people (Bay Area Air Quality Management District)

 

Key Takeaways

  • Vulnerable groups (e.g., low-income communities) should be actively targeted and supported and should be consulted during the design phase.
  •  A strong, systematic governmental framework to address equity challenges can help increase affordability (e.g., targeted incentives) and accessibility (e.g., developing infrastructure, public outreach) of sustainable alternatives.

Year published
01 October 2024
Equity Dimension
Access to goods and services
Green Transition Dimension
Greening transportation and mobility
Implementing Entity
Public (sub-national)
Scope
Regional