mobile image

Nestle Income Accelerator: Incentivising farmers to accelerate adoption of sustainable practices

Summary

Nestle is committed to sustainable practices and innovation, focusing on nutrition, health, and wellness to meet the evolving needs of consumers globally. The company has committed to halving its emissions by 2030 and achieving Net Zero by 2050.


This case study focuses on an Income accelerator programme with the aim of reducing the living income gap for cocoa farmers as well as reducing child labor risks while encouraging use of sustainable practices. The programme also has a focus on vulnerable groups such as farmers in rural areas and women. This programme illustrates the role that corporations can play in incentivising the adoption of sustainable regenerative practices amongst farmers in its supply chain.

Challenge

The global cocoa beans sector is valued at approximately $16B annually and is projected to grow by almost 7% per year to over $22B by 2028 (Dutch Centre). However, farmers who produce cocoa face persistent and extreme poverty rates, struggling to make a living income. 100% of cocoa is grown in the Global South—with Cote d’Ivoire and Ghana contributing more than 60% of global output (UCL).

 

Cocoa farmers in West Africa typically earn low incomes, often living below the poverty line. Despite the high global demand for chocolate, the benefits are not equitably distributed along the supply chain with many cocoa farmers earning less than $1 per day—far below the living income benchmark​​ (Guardian). This economic disparity is exacerbated by issues such as child labor, lack of access to education, and inadequate healthcare.

 

Cocoa farming has been a significant contributor to climate change and deforestation. The production of 1kg of cocoa beans is associated with an average greenhouse gas emission of 1.47 kg CO2e (Vervuurt et al, 2022). The industry is also vulnerable to impacts of climate change given the high sensitivity of cocoa trees to changes in temperature and rainfall patterns. Due to this, many chocolate producers are attempting to address the challenging considerations of cocoa growing by increasing support for sustainable agricultural practices and setting up programmes to improve livelihoods of cocoa farmers.

Programme Goal and Expected Outcomes

The Income Accelerator Programme is aimed at improving the livelihoods of cocoa farmers, while also increasing the adoption of sustainable agricultural practices. The programme additionally focuses on vulnerable groups such as children that might be used as forced labour and women.

 

The Accelerator was first piloted in 2021 with 1000 farming households in Cote d’Ivoire. Following the pilot’s success, it was expanded to 10,000 additional households in Cote d’Ivoire in a “test-at-scale” phase. Nestle aims to continue expanding the size and geographic scope of the programme with 30,000 additional household in Ghana to be included in 2024. The ultimate aim is global expansion to an estimated 160,000 cocoa-farming households (Kit progress report).

 

The programme targets four key areas (Nestle):


  • Implement good agricultural practices to increase crop productivity e.g. pruning
  • Perform agroforestry activities to increase climate resilience e.g. planting shade trees
  • Generate diversified income for cocoa farmers e.g. through growing other crops, raising livestock such as chickens or selling vegetables from community-led gardens
  • Incentivise school enrolment of children in cocoa farming families aged 6-16 to reduce child labour risks

Key strategies (Kit progress report) include:

  1. Offering incentives: The programme is structured such that households receive a 100EUR cash transfer for each of the four key areas they participate in. Households also receive an extra 100EUR for participating in all four key areas, equally shared between the head male and female of the household. This encourages participants to partake in the full programme.
  2. Subsidized technical training: To boost cocoa farm productivity, subsidized, professionally trained pruning groups are established to serve all households involved in the Accelerator program. These groups provide support on Good Agricultural Practices (GAP) for a critical activity in the cocoa growing process.
  3. Provision of plants: Regenerative practices are implemented through agroforestry initiatives, including the planting of fruit and shade trees on cocoa farms. In 2022, 208,845 fruit and shade trees from Nestlé’s nurseries were distributed to eligible households and planted with assistance from the pruning groups. This number rose to 237,552 seedlings in 2023.
  4. Financial education: To encourage diversified incomes, households, especially women, receive training through Village Savings and Loan Associations (VSLAs). These groups help women save and borrow money to invest in Income Generating Activities (IGAs). Additionally, women's financial inclusion is promoted by registering them for Mobile Money (MoMo) accounts, which are used to receive half of the cash transfers provided by the Accelerator.

Enabling Conditions

Two key factors enable Nestle’s work in the programme:

  • Aligning incentives directly to specific programme goals effectively encourages participation. Ensuring that incentives are shared equally among household members, particularly between genders, can further promote inclusivity and shared responsibility.
  • By promoting financial education and establishing Village Savings and Loan Associations, Nestle empowered farmers, particularly women, to diversify their income sources and improve financial resilience. This model can be replicated to encourage savings, provide access to credit, and promote diversified income-generating activities, enhancing community economic stability.

Indicators of Success

  • Good agricultural practices: Farmers in the Income Accelerator programme reported higher crop productivity with 32% increase in kg/ha cocoa production vs 15% in comparison group. 75% of participating households achieved high-quality pruning, and nearly 70% adopted sufficient Good Agricultural Practices (GAP), including pruning, pest and shade tree management, weeding, and harvesting, as assessed by Rainforest Alliance standards. (Kit progress report)
  • Agroforestry activities: In 2022, 208,845 fruit and shade trees from Nestlé’s nurseries were distributed to eligible households and planted with assistance from the pruning groups. This number rose to 237,552 seedlings in 2023. According to 2023 survey data, 82% of households in the Accelerator program achieved a sufficient score in shade tree management practices, using Rainforest Alliance standards, compared to 47% in the comparison group – a group of ~100 households who are not part of the Income Accelerator (Kit progress report)
  • Diversified income: In 2023, a total of 494 Village Savings and Loan Associations (VSLAs) were established in 146 communities, with 7,912 households participating. Gender Action Learning System (GALS) training was conducted in 355 of the VSLAs. Accelerator households increased their earnings from cocoa sales by 51% compared to 31% in the comparison group. Also, more women in the household were financially empowered in with 79% of women registered in a Village Savings and Loans Association vs 47% in the comparison group (Kit progress report)
  • School enrolment: School enrolment increased due to the programme with 89% of children from households in the programme being enrolled in school vs 86% in comparison group (Kit progress report)

Key Takeaways/Implications

  • Nestle's use of structured cash incentives effectively encouraged participation in sustainable practices, while the provision of subsidized technical training and professional support groups ensured farmers could successfully implement these practices. Other organizations can adopt similar strategies to drive engagement and provide the necessary support for sustainable adoption.
  • Nestle's focus on reducing child labour and empowering women underscores the importance of addressing social issues alongside economic goals. Programs designed to support vulnerable populations and distribute benefits equitably can improve both social welfare and economic outcomes, providing a holistic approach to community development.

Year published
02 October 2024
Green Transition Dimension
Greening Agriculture & Food Production
Equity Dimension
Access to Capacity, Access to Financing and Investments
Implementing Entity
Private
Scope
International